In
the larger scope of marketing, a debate has been
pushed to the forefront by ad-blocking technologies
such as TiVO. Consumer choice and their permission
to allow such ad-blocking is the essential issue,
and one that will continue to rage offline and
online.
In
the online sphere, many marketers and small
publishers who rely on affiliate links and programs
such as AdWords have raised this issue of
ad-blocking as it relates to their bottom line. As
many small publishers and affiliates rely so heavily
on the monetary income provided by the links and ads
being blocked, the issue has a new relevancy for our
industry. Although this part of the online
marketing sphere is frequently overlooked and
undervalued, it is important to weigh how ad
blocking technologies affect them, and our industry
at large.
For
instance, Norton Internet Security and Firewall are
blocking many affiliate links, ad banners, AdWords,
Adsense and even text links. It may even be blocking
your own site logo or your family pictures if they
are a certain image size.
When I say "blocked" I mean erased, wiped out and
invisible. It leaves a blank white spot where the
banners or text links should have been, making it
look like your site is defective or you are missing
information. It does not just block ads, it
literally strips the source code out of the page.
I have been researching this issue for a while now
and recently downloaded the software to start
testing. I'm surprised how this software defaces
websites and can effect advertisers, webmaster and
affiliate revenue! Even though these products are
sold as “Security” the default is set to block ads,
so for non- savvy users that don't realize how much
information Norton can block, they will just think
your site is poorly designed or information is
missing when they see all the white spaces.
This is evidenced by the
fact that more and more webmasters are receiving
customer email saying "I want to buy something on
your site but there is no link, how can I buy this."
See examples here:
http://www.5staraffiliateprograms.com/norton-blocks-revenue.html
If
you don’t think this is a big problem yet, I say -
think again!
Norton IS 2004, is being shipped with many new
computers so I think this problem will grow. See
this March 1 2004 Symantec press release stating
that “Symantec Security
Software Ships on Nine of Top 10 Notebook Computers
Worldwide.” “…According
to research firm IDC, notebooks are the fastest
growing PC market segment, and sales of notebooks
have now surpassed those of desktops…”
http://www.symantec.com/press/2004/n040301.html.
I
am not an affiliate or a merchant, so I have not
personally suffered any loss of revenue. I am an
affiliate management consultant and it’s my job to
help clients (etailers) and affiliates make money
online. So I share this info in an effort to help
others become aware of the issue and discover
potential solutions which could help protect your
online revenues.
This issue is being hotly debated on webmaster
forums across the net. Some say Norton has the
right to do whatever they want with their software.
Others say it is the user’s choice and if they want
to block ads they should be allowed to. (Choice is a
key issue here!)
Aside from the fact that this software is cutting
into ad revenues here are other issues that I think
need to be addressed.
PRODUCT REPRESENTATION – Both Norton Internet
Security and Personal Firewall are sold as
“security” products, designed to protect users from
the “threats” of the Internet and malicious
“intrusions.” The products own ad claims “provides
essential protection from viruses, hackers, and
privacy threats. Although the ad-blocking feature
is briefly mentioned on the product’s webpage, the
issue is still relevant because of the default
setting. See
http://www.symantec.com/sabu/nis/nis_pe/
AD
BLOCKING DEFAULTS – Since these products are sold as
Security products, Ad Blocking should be an option
users can turn on, it should not be the default.
Popups are intrusive, banner ads can take additional
load time, but text links should not be blocked.
Regardless, unless this product is labeled clearly
as an ad blocker, the default should be off and it
should be the users CHOICE to turn it on.
AD
BLOCKING WARNINGS - There should also be clear
labeling in the interface and on the box warning
that there may be large blank spaces on web sites
and links and navigation may be missing or may not
work properly due to the blocking features. Numerous
web sites are getting tech support calls due to
users that want to purchase and can’t see links or
think that the site is defective. Even the
Washington Post has had to address the Norton issue
in their help files here:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/admin/help/#q1
TEXT LINKS – Text links are not intrusive and do not
eat up bandwidth. According to Symantec help – text
based ads are not supposed to be blocked, yet
they are, including Google Adwords and Adsense.
Norton’s help files state that Ad Blocking does NOT
remove text links, yet it does. See examples here:
http://www.5staraffiliateprograms.com/norton-blocks-revenue.html
COPYWRITE AND PROPERTY ISSUES
Norton does not just block ads, it literally strips
the source code out of the page. Even if a user
disables ad blocking and then hits refresh to try to
view a page, the content does not show up in most
cases. Norton also by virtue of it’s targeting of
standard banner size images, can strip out logos,
family pictures and any other images that happen to
be a certain size. Sometimes links essential for
navigating the site, that have nothing to do with
ads are even stripped out. See this example of
www.Phillyburbs.com, a popular local online
newspaper and how Norton has stripped not only the
top banner ads but also the right navigation links.http://www.5staraffiliateprograms.com/phillyblocked.html
On
the page below you will be able to see numerous
examples, find links, articles and some forums where
the issue has been raised by others with suggestions
on how to remedy the situation. The links I have
compiled are too numerous to list in this article so
please see bottom of this page:
http://www.5staraffiliateprograms.com/norton-blocks-revenue.html
Again, I have nothing to gain personally by writing
about this. I simply believe affiliates and online
advertisers face too many threats to their online
revenue from parasites, hijackers, hackers, fraud
and other unscrupulous activities as it is.
Internet marketers should not have to worry about
protecting their livelihoods from a big company like
Symantec that bundles aggressive, default ON ad
blocking technology in with security products that
play into surfer’s fear and are just supposed to
keep the web safe. The name Symantec is synonymous
with “security” and virus protection, they don’t
even sell ad related software. If Symantec was
blocking ads with a product called “Ad Blocker
2004,” then people would only buy it if they
specifically wanted to block ads.
The
main issue of consumer choice is at stake in the
broader scope of what this issue presents.
Ad-blocking technologies will continue to be made
available to the consumer by an industry eager to
cater to the wants of individuals looking for fewer
advertisements in their web browsing. As an
industry, we must face the challenge that these
ad-blocking technologies present to our profits and
to the issue of consumer choice. However, by
pointing out specific instances of how companies are
presenting these ad-blocking technologies and their
ramifications for a large part of online direct
marketing, we can come to a better consensus on how
to face this important issue.
About the Author:
Linda Buquet, is an Affiliate Management Consultant
representing high paying, parasite-free affiliate
programs which can be found by visiting her site at:
http://www.5staraffiliateprograms.com/